Table layout vs CSS layout ...

Discussion in 'Coding Help' started by dbee, Jul 10, 2007.


Table layout vs CSS layout

  1. Table layout

    0 vote(s)
  2. CSS layout

    0 vote(s)
  3. What's CSS layout ?

    0 vote(s)
  1. dbee

    dbee New Member

    Who uses tables for their html layout ? Who uses CSS for their layout ?
  2. enzo

    enzo New Member

    I had a css layout and I switched to tables for stability (because I couldn't test on different platforms). I've planned to go back to CSS but have been too lazy... :eek:
  3. ph3n0m

    ph3n0m New Member

    Mostly CSS/div layouts - but there is always a time and place for tables :)
  4. CiaranR

    CiaranR Weeno Ltd +

    its called Tabular Data - that it realy
  5. ph3n0m

    ph3n0m New Member

    Indeed it is.
  6. louie

    louie New Member

    mostly divs but when (as said above ) it comes to tabular data tables are still the king as it maintains width constrains.
  7. babyboy808

    babyboy808 New Member

    Yep, css all the way, but I'm getting into a bad habit of not validating my own projects... :eek:
  8. ph3n0m

    ph3n0m New Member

    and its easy to align text to the bottom :)
  9. wheres me jumpa

    wheres me jumpa New Member

    CSS for me also. The layouts I create, I could create in tables but I just find CSS easier to write.
  10. TheMenace

    TheMenace New Member

    It's not the middle ages anymore, so I'll have to go with CSS-based layouts with tables only used for tabular data.
  11. CiaranR

    CiaranR Weeno Ltd +

    Have to agree with you there (not that anyone's dis-agreeing, I just couldn't think how else to start the post, and now I'm rambling)
    I first learned layout in tables but then switched to div's and css and once I got over the learning curve I found them so much quicker and easier to write.

    There quite a few things with them that you will only learn through hours of coding and practice (fluid layouts, 2 column same length layout, box model stuff) but once you get them down you can write layouts so easy.
  12. davidbehan

    davidbehan New Member

    CSS all the way baby!!!!

    I've been designing sites for about 6 years and some of the sites I still manage from a few years ago (before my move from the dark side) are coded in tables. I actually cringe every time I have to work with those sites cause I have to deal with spacer.gif, column width/height, hundreds of lines of code, etc. Argh!!!

    If I had a test of chopping up a design and doing it in tables first and then in CSS, I'd say I'd be twice as quick in CSS (that's if I'd get that far cause I'd probably go completely mad during the table design part).

    Does anyone remember the time just before you moved from table design to css? I found it so hard to get the idea, concept, etc. I had tried it a few times and just couldn't get to grips with it. I remember the first project I used pure CSS and I was sooooo chuffed to get it working. I think that's about 2/3 years ago now but they were the days that I didn't like Firefox and hated fixing sites for it. How naive I was!!! I couldn't live with FF and Firebug these days!

    Oh if you don't know already... install Firebug into FF. It lets you modify the CSS on the fly and see the changes immediately in the browser (as well as loads of other things). Great for quickly testing your CSS layout changes!

    Cheers, Dave! :)
  13. TheMenace

    TheMenace New Member

    I have to say, it's a bit of a strange question to be asking in 2007. Anyone who proudly claims to lay out their sites using tables at this stage should be considered terminally retarded.
  14. ph3n0m

    ph3n0m New Member

    OOooh you lazy bugger - so you got sick of pressing Alt/Tab and then pressing F5 to refresh your browser? I dont know, you kids and your ways
  15. Oh hell yes, it's a whole other mindset IMHO.
  16. CiaranR

    CiaranR Weeno Ltd +

    That's a bit harsh to be honest. I know people who code with tables simply because they were taught that way. They wouldn't be coding for a living but run a few hobby sites. Just because someone is uneducated doesn't mean they are retarded. Learning CSS could be quite daunting if you have been coding for a number of years and if you are of the opinion "if it ain't broke don't fix it" you may well be proudly coding with tables.
  17. TheMenace

    TheMenace New Member

    *sigh* In this irritating PC world we really do have to elaborate on everything we say, don't we? :rolleyes:

    Let me try again... *ahem*

    "Anyone working in this industry in a professional capacity who proudly claims to lay out their sites using tables at this stage should be considered terminally retarded."
  18. CiaranR

    CiaranR Weeno Ltd +

    Sorry Ken didn't mean to be awkward, just being PC as you say, don't like the way that word is bandied about.
  19. dbee

    dbee New Member

    I think labelling someone retarded, isn't PC in any world ...

    Glad to hear that people are designing to reasonable standards though. There's a company near me who design all their pages unvalidated, with no doc type and using tables ....

    I was hoping that wasn't the general norm ...
  20. TheMenace

    TheMenace New Member

    True. I'm not the least bit PC. And proud of it.

    I think it is in many cases unfortunately.

Share This Page